2012 Baseball All-Conference Team
Player of the Year - Tom Henke (Webster)
Pitcher of the Year - David Mueller (Webster)
Newcomer of the Year - Isaac Behme (Webster)
Coach of the Year - Bill Kurich (Webster)
Sportsmanship Award - Blackburn College
| First Team | ||||
| Name | Position | School | Year | Hometown/High School |
| Drew Schelerth | P | Fontbonne | Jr | St. Louis, Mo./Affton |
| Tyler Pilcher | P | Greenville | Fr | Effingham, Ill./Effingham |
| David Mueller | P | Webster | Sr | Webster Groves, Mo./Westminster Christian Academy |
| Matt Moore | C | Webster | Sr | Colorado Springs, Colo./St. Joseph's College |
| Tom Henke | 1B | Webster | Sr | St. Louis, Mo./Forest Park CC |
| Bryan Clemmons | 2B | Spalding | Sr | Louisville, Ky./IUSE |
| Kenny Trager | 3B | Greenville | Jr | Denver, Colo./Green Mountain |
| Derek Ferch | SS | Spalding | So | Louisville, Ky./St. Xavier |
| Donny Furhop | OF | Blackburn | So | St. Jacob, Ill./Triad |
| Alex Kazmierski | OF | Webster | Jr | Orland Park, Ill./Triton College |
| Cody Stevenson | OF | Webster | Jr | Salem, Ill./Centralia |
| Cameron Norris | DH | Spalding | Jr | Louisville, Ky./Murray State |
| Alan Cheatham | UT | Principia | Sr | Rancho Santa Fe, Calif./Canyon Crest Academy |
| David Massengill | UT | Greenville | Sr | Greenup, Ill./Cumberland |
| Second Team | ||||
| Name | Position | School | Year | Hometown/High School |
| Greg Ball | P | Principia | Sr | Orlando, Fla./Edgewater |
| Taylor Reilly | P | Spalding | Sr | Louisville, Ky./IUSE |
| Isaac Behme | P | Webster | Fr | Harrisburg, Ill./Harrisburg |
| Aaron Krummrich | C | MacMurray | Fr | Belleville, Ill./Belleville East |
| Ryan Smith | 1B | Greenville | Fr | Affton, Mo./Affton |
| Kyle Tipton | 2B | Fontbonne | So | Arnold, Mo./Fox |
| Donnie Johnson | 3B | MacMurray | Fr | Carrollton, Ill./Carrollton |
| Taylor Stoulp | SS | Webster | So | St. Louis, Mo./St. Mary's |
| Sean Fisher | OF | Fontbonne | Jr | Thousand Oaks, Calif./Crespi Carmelite |
| Mark O'Moran | OF | Fontbonne | Fr | St. Louis, Mo./Mehlville |
| Kyle Just | OF | Spalding | Sr | Louisville, Ky./St. Xavier |
| Mike Rainbolt | DH | Webster | Jr | Kankakee, Ill./Kankakee CC |
| Honorable Mention | ||||
| Name | Position | School | Year | Hometown/High School |
| Tyler Brown | P | Spalding | So | Joliet, Ill./Joliet West |
| Kyle Hudson | P | Spalding | Jr | Herrin, Ill./Rend Lake |
| Cody Hafeli | P | Webster | Jr | Marian, Ill./Kankakee CC |
| Josh Hofer | C | Eureka | Jr | Washington, Ill./Washington |
| Jordan Phillips | 1B | MacMurray | Jr | Belleville, Ill./SWIC |
| Zane Wheatley | 1B | Spalding | Jr | Louisville, Ky./DeSales |
| Dylan Goldsmith | 2B | Greenville | So | Nokomis, Ill./Nokomis |
| Zeth Lavy | 3B | Westminster (Mo.) | Jr | Auxvasse, Mo./North Callaway |
| Grant DeWitt | SS | Eureka | So | Mt. Sterling, Ill./Brown County |
| Eric Lopez | OF | Eureka | Jr | Oak Lawn, Ill./Lakes |
| Cole Lawson | OF | Greenville | Jr | Medora, Ill./Southwestern |
| Wyatt Matteson | OF | Greenville | Fr | Greenup, Ill./Cumberland |
| Gavin Thomas | DH | Principia | Fr | Chesterfield, Mo./Principia Upper School |
| Blake McConkey | UT | Eureka | Sr | Fairview, Ill./Spoon River Valley |
| All-Sportsmanship Team | ||||
| Name | School | |||
| Ian Andrews | Blackburn | |||
| Michael Hammerstrand | Eureka | |||
| Justin Head | Fontbonne | |||
| Adam Wallace | Greenville | |||
| Nathan Loy | MacMurray | |||
| Greg Ball | Principia | |||
| Eric Johnson | Spalding | |||
| Michael Aaron | Webster | |||
| Jake Rule | Westminster (Mo.) |
