2011 Baseball All-Conference Team
Player of the Year - Anthony Genna (Webster)
Pitcher of the Year - Tyler Brown (Spalding)
Newcomer of the Year - Tyler Brown (Spalding)
Coach of the Year - Mike Stawski (Spalding)
Sportsmanship Award - Principia College
| First Team | ||||
| Name | Position | School | Year | Hometown/High School |
| Greg Ball | P | Principia | Jr | Orlando, Fla./ |
| Jake Wardrip | P | Spalding | Sr | Louisville, Ky./St. Xavier |
| Tyler Brown | P | Spalding | ||
| Steven Schanz | C | Spalding | ||
| Andrew Jett | 1B | Westminster (Mo.) | Sr | Owensville, Mo./Owensville |
| Kyle Hobar | 2B | Greenville | Sr | Germantown, Tenn./Kings |
| Bryan Clemmons | 2B | Spalding | ||
| Nathan Shelton | 3B | Webster | Sr | Dittmer, Mo./Northwest |
| Anthony Genna | SS | Webster | Sr | Willow Springs, Ill./Lyons Township |
| Daniel Covert | OF | Greenville | Sr | Trenton, Ill./Wesclin |
| Cody Stevenson | OF | Webster | So | Salem, Ill./Centralia |
| Paul Kienker | OF | Webster | Sr | Eureka, Mo./St. John Vianney |
| David Massengil | UT | Greenville | Sr | Neoga, Ill./ |
| Alan Cheatham | DH | Principia | Jr | Rancho Santa Fe, Calif./Canyon Crest Academy |
| Second Team | ||||
| Name | Position | School | Year | Hometown/High School |
| Jason Gray | P | Webster | Jr | St. Louis, Mo./North Central CC |
| David Mueller | P | Webster | Jr | Webster Groves, Mo./Westminster Christian Academy |
| Zach Schneider | P | Webster | Fr | Grayslake, Ill./Warren Township |
| Alex Hess | C | Eureka | Sr | Washington, Ill./Washington |
| Tom Henke | 1B | Webster | Jr | St. Louis, Mo./Forest Park CC |
| Blake McConkey | 3B | Eureka | Jr | Fairview, Ill./Spoon River Valley |
| Spencer Brown | SS | Principia | Sr | Camarillo, Calif./Viewpoint School |
| Jordan Messex | OF | Spalding | ||
| V.J. Reynolds | OF | Westminster (Mo.) | Sr | St. Charles, Mo./Francis Howell Central |
| Jason Nikolaisen | OF | Fontbonne | Sr | St. Louis, Mo./Mehlville |
| Kyle Just | UT | Spalding | ||
| Craig Schaefer | DH | Webster | Sr | Carterville, Ill./Carterville |
| Honorable Mention | ||||
| Name | Position | School | Year | Hometown/High School |
| Brad Schoneman | P | Fontbonne | Jr | Longmont, Colo./ |
| David Willey | P | Fontbonne | Sr | St. Louis, Mo./ |
| Taylor Reilly | P | Spalding | ||
| Steve Dooley | P | Webster | So | Oran, Mo./Florissant Valley CC |
| Nick Hoag | C | Westminster (Mo.) | Jr | St. Louis, Mo./Lindbergh |
| Tim Cashdollar | 1B | Eureka | Sr | Morton, Ill./Morton |
| Jake Jurczak | 2B | Blackburn | Sr | Danville, Ill./ |
| Nick Platipodis | 3B | Fontbonne | So | St. Louis, Mo./ |
| Franklin Bush | SS | Blackburn | So | Auburn, Ala./ |
| Mick Ritter | SS | Fontbonne | Jr | Grand Junction, Colo./ |
| Derek Ferch | SS | Spalding | ||
| Matt Suda | OF | Fontbonne | So | St. Louis, Mo./ |
| Matt Mallette | OF | Westminster (Mo.) | So | St. Louis, Mo./St. Mary's |
| Nick Cronin | DH | Blackburn | Sr | Zion, Ill./ |
| Kevin Moritz | DH | Westminster (Mo.) | So | Chesterfield, Mo./DeSmet |
| All-Sportsmanship Team | ||||
| Name | School | |||
| Franklin Bush | Blackburn | |||
| Tim Cashdollar | Eureka | |||
| Matt Suda | Fontbonne | |||
| Adam Wallace | Greenville | |||
| David Johnson | MacMurray | |||
| Greg Ball | Principia | |||
| Barrett Dugger | Spalding | |||
| Nathan Shelton | Webster | |||
| V.J. Reynolds | Westminster (Mo.) |
