2009 Baseball All-Conference Team
Player of the Year - Andy Fuiten (Webster)
Newcomer of the Year - Joe Biagini (Webster)
Coach of the Year - Bill Kurich (Webster)
Sportsmanship Award - Principia College
| First Team | ||||
| Name | Position | School | Year | Hometown/High School |
| Alex Kollack | P | Maryville (Mo.) | Jr | Dupo, Ill./Dupo |
| Will Savage | P | Webster | Jr | Lisle, Ill./Benet Academy |
| Bryan Stanley | P | Webster | Jr | Elgin, Ill./(Elgin CC) |
| Dan Horn | C | Fontbonne | Sr | Affton, Mo./Vianney |
| Josh Holman | 1B | Blackburn | Sr | Morris, Ill./Morris |
| Aaron Senzell | 2B | Webster | Jr | Evansville, Ind./(Vincennes Univ.) |
| Nathan Shelton | 3B | Webster | So | Dittmer, Mo./Northwest |
| Zach Little | SS | Webster | Jr | St. Louis, Mo./Florissant Valley CC) |
| Adam Boyer | OF | Maryville (Mo.) | Jr | St. Louis, Mo./Oakville |
| Andy Fuiten | OF | Webster | Sr | Decatur, Ill./(Lincoln College) |
| Dakota Huey | OF | Webster | Jr | Highland, Ill./(Murray State) |
| Chris Stenzel | UT | Maryville (Mo.) | Jr | Red Bud, Ill./Red Bud |
| Joe Biagini | DH | Webster | Fr | Glen Ellyn, Ill./Glenbard South |
| Second Team | ||||
| Name | Position | School | Year | Hometown/High School |
| Andy Rincker | P | Greenville | Sr | Strasburg, Ill./Stewardson-Strasburg |
| Eric Broughton | P | Webster | Sr | Petersburg, Ill./(Lincoln College) |
| Bryce Law | P | Webster | Jr | Rochelle, Ill./(Vincennes Univ.) |
| Craig Schaefer | C | Webster | So | Carterville, Ill./Carterville |
| Matt Bowman | 1B | Principia | So | Woodland Hills, Calif./ |
| Kyle Starnes | 1B | Webster | Sr | Sugarland, Texas/(Baylor) |
| Bill Allerdissen | 2B | Maryville (Mo.) | Sr | Glencoe, Mo./Lafayette |
| Robert Huckstep | 3B | Maryville (Mo.) | Jr | Fenton, Mo./Rockwood Summit |
| Jared Mills | SS | Maryville (Mo.) | Jr | Iowa City, Iowa/Regina |
| Josh Burlison | OF | Fontbonne | Jr | Barnhart, Mo./Windsor |
| Bryan Hobbie | OF | Greenville | Sr | Vandalia, Ill./Vandalia Community |
| Mike Silver | OF | Westminster (Mo.) | Sr | Florissant, Mo./McCluer |
| Andrew Jett | UT | Westminster (Mo.) | So | Owensville, Mo./Owensville (Meramec CC) |
| Honorable Mention | ||||
| Name | Position | School | Year | Hometown/High School |
| Ben Eilerman | P | Blackburn | Jr | Batchtown, Ill./Hardin-Calhoun |
| Clay McConkey | P | Eureka | Jr | Fairview, Ill./Spoon River Valley |
| Jack Grover | P | Fontbonne | Sr | St. Louis, Mo./Vianney |
| James Backstein | C | MacMurray | Sr | Rochester, Ill./Rochester |
| Josh Kraemer | 1B | Fontbonne | Jr | Barnhart, Mo./Windsor |
| Brian Stoff | 1B | Greenville | Sr | Highland, Ill./Highland |
| Kyle Hobar | 2B | Greenville | So | Maineville, Ohio/Kings |
| John Raffles | 2B | Principia | Sr | Lake Forest, Ill./ |
| Adam Cadle | 3B | Blackburn | Jr | Marion, Ill./Marion |
| Evan White | 3B | Westminster (Mo.) | Fr | Milan, Ill./Sherrard |
| Spencer Brown | SS | Principia | So | Camarillo, Calif./ |
| Keith Moore | OF | Eureka | Sr | Hamilton, Ill./Hamilton |
| Mike Scott | OF | Greenville | Sr | Indianapolis, Ind./Ben Davis |
| John Norvell | OF | Maryville (Mo.) | Fr |
Wildwood, Mo./Eureka |
| Alan Cheatham | UT | Principia | Fr | Rancho Santa Fe, Calif./ |
