Nicole Moyer was a four-year letter winner for the Griffins volleyball team. She earned All-Conference honors in each of her four years, including Second Team honors as a freshman and sophomore and First Team honors as a junior and senior. Moyer was also named SLIAC Newcomer of the Year in 2001 and SLIAC Player of the Year in 2003 and 2004. In addition to her individual honors, Moyer also helped lead Fontbonne to four consecutive SLIAC Championships and NCAA Tournament appearances. During her four years the Griffins compiled an overall record of 73-34 and 54-2 in the SLIAC.
On the court, Moyer led her team in several statistical categories and still holds two Fontbonne records to this day. She finished her outstanding career with 1,370 kills, which ranks as No. 1 in Griffins history. Moyer tallied a season-high 421 kills as a junior and also had a school record .289 hitting percentage during her senior season.